Melting Arctic ice opens new front in strategic power competition

Warming seas and thinning polar ice caps promise to show the Arctic right into a hub of higher financial exercise — and a brand new hotspot for navy competitors.

That prospect is shaping U.S. navy technique for Arctic operations and is drawing consideration to the significance of area methods to maintain watch over the area, monitor the local weather and keep fixed communications.

“This can be a area of immense geostrategic significance and a key location for international energy projection,” mentioned the Division of the Air Power’s Arctic technique revealed in 2020.

The Arctic area surrounding the North Pole is greater than twice the dimensions of the continental United States. The realm is especially reliant on air and area property as a result of its dimension, inhospitable climate and lack of infrastructure.

The U.S. Air Power and House Power present about 80% of all Protection Division assets within the Arctic area, together with navy bases, coaching complexes, satellites, command and management stations, and early warning and missile protection radars.

“The Arctic is de facto key terrain for us,” the House Power chief of area operations Gen. John “Jay” Raymond, advised table4 in a current interview.

“Now we have invested, and we proceed to put money into the Arctic. It’s of strategic significance to us, and it’s solely going to proceed to develop in significance to our nation,” says Chief of House Operations Gen. John Raymond, proven above shaking palms with an airman at Thule Air Base, Greenland. Credit score: DoD

At Clear House Power Station close to Fairbanks, Alaska, the U.S. Missile Protection Company final yr accomplished building of a long-range discrimination radar, designed to trace ballistic missiles. House Power models will begin working the radar in 2023.

Raymond famous that the Pentagon’s 2023 finances request consists of $68 million to construct dormitories for troops anticipated to be completely based mostly at Clear. Thule Air Base in Greenland is also house to missile warning, area monitoring, and satellite tv for pc command-and-control models.

“Now we have invested, and we proceed to put money into the Arctic,” mentioned Raymond. “It’s of strategic significance to us, and it’s solely going to proceed to develop in significance to our nation.”

Clear House Power Station is one in every of 5 main installations the U.S. navy operates in Alaska. The others are Joint Base Elmendorf-Richardson, Eielson Air Power Base, Fort Wainwright and Fort Greely.

In its Arctic technique, final up to date in 2019, the Protection Division described the area as a possible vector for an assault on the U.S. homeland and part of the world the place Russia and China are working extra freely. The technique mentioned DoD “should have the ability to shortly establish threats within the Arctic, reply promptly and successfully to these threats, and form the safety surroundings to mitigate the prospect of these threats sooner or later.”

In 2021, the U.S. Military and Navy revealed visions for learn how to posture for the Arctic. These paperwork spotlight the potential for battle over maritime boundary claims and financial rights.

Russia, for instance, requires overseas vessels to acquire permission and be escorted throughout transit of the Northern Sea Route that runs alongside the Russian Arctic coast to the Bering Strait, famous the Military’s technique. “The lowering quantity of sea ice will result in new routes opening sooner or later and should grow to be an space of rivalry as Arctic nations try and exert management over key sea lanes.”

For the Navy, the difficulty is what all this might imply for maritime safety. Regardless of containing the world’s smallest ocean, the Arctic area has the potential to attach almost 75% of the world’s inhabitants — linking Asia, Europe and North America, mentioned the Navy’s imaginative and prescient doc.


Overseeing U.S. navy operations within the Arctic is Gen. Glen VanHerck, head of U.S. Northern Command and North American Aerospace Protection Command.

VanHerck advised lawmakers throughout a listening to this spring on Capitol Hill that navy efforts within the Arctic are supposed to guarantee the realm stays “peaceable, steady and cooperative.” He famous that the USA is one in every of eight nations that in 1996 shaped the Arctic Council. The opposite seven members are Canada, Denmark, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Russia and Sweden.

There are actually considerations that as Russia turns into extra remoted following its invasion of Ukraine, it might take a extra aggressive posture within the Arctic. Russia’s jap border is just 90 kilometers throughout the Bering Strait from the coast of Alaska.

VanHerck famous that 25 p.c of Russia’s gross home product comes from oil, minerals and different pure assets extracted within the Arctic. “So that they completely have a vested curiosity within the Arctic, they usually additionally wish to be sure that it’s safe for his or her efforts.”

Over the previous a number of years, Russia has revitalized a dozen or so navy installations within the Arctic that had sat dormant after the Chilly Struggle, mentioned VanHerck. “Not solely are they inserting defensive capabilities that they state are clearly for defensive functions, they’re placing offensive capabilities into the Arctic,” he mentioned, together with missiles that might strike North America.

Russia shaped the Northern Fleet Joint Strategic Command in December 2014 to coordinate efforts within the Arctic. Since then, DoD mentioned in its technique doc, Russia has step by step strengthened its presence by creating new Arctic models, refurbishing previous airfields and infrastructure, and establishing navy bases alongside its Arctic shoreline.

Russia additionally has been working to ascertain a community of air protection and coastal missile methods, early warning radars and rescue facilities, the DoD technique mentioned. In February 2021, Russia launched the Arktika-M satellite tv for pc to watch the local weather and surroundings within the area.

The US can be watching China’s strikes within the Arctic. “China calls itself a near-Arctic nation and needs to be influential within the Arctic as effectively,” mentioned VanHerck.

Regarding U.S. capabilities, “I’d assess that we’re within the recreation plan improvement,” he advised the Home Armed Companies Committee. “We’re not capable of have the persistence that I must compete day-to-day within the Arctic.”

One other looming concern for DoD is how local weather change might affect U.S. navy infrastructure within the Arctic. The problem was investigated just lately by the division’s inspector common, who concluded in a report final month that DoD might want to make investments billions of {dollars} to make navy installations within the Arctic and sub-Arctic extra resilient to local weather change.

The IG evaluated Thule Air Base in Greenland and DoD’s 5 navy bases in Alaska.

“Officers from all six installations recognized present local weather and vitality challenges, akin to cracked runways, sunken foundations, and a number of energy outages,” mentioned the IG report. At most of those installations, the “day-to-day focus was on reacting to fast issues or lowering threat to present hazards, somewhat than planning for future hazards.”

The report mentioned some building initiatives at Military, Air Power and House Power installations are already being funded to assist elevated Arctic operations.


There’s a big want within the Arctic for dependable surveillance and communications methods as a result of miscommunications might set off unintended battle, Lt. Gen. S. Clinton Hinote, deputy chief of workers for Air Power Futures, mentioned at a Wilson Middle panel dialogue.

“Consciousness about what’s going on within the Arctic is a key a part of preserving peace,” he mentioned.

For instance, in navy wargames, the “avenues of approaches over the Arctic” for enemy missiles or bombers are a significant concern. “The Arctic is the shortest route between our rivals and us.”

The U.S. Air Power has operated within the Arctic for many years, Hinote mentioned. “However our use of the Arctic as a strategic buffer is eroding for all the explanations which were talked about, particularly local weather change, and particularly with a few of the actions that we see Russia and China partaking in.”

The Lengthy Vary Discrimination Radar at Clear House Power Station, Alaska, features a multi-face radar designed to supply search, monitor and discrimination functionality in assist of homeland protection. The complicated additionally features a mission management facility, energy plant and upkeep facility. Credit score: Missile Protection Company

Because the Arctic melts, “competitors for assets and affect within the area will improve,” he mentioned.

Hinote mentioned the U.S. Air Power in recent times has intercepted and warned away a rising variety of Russian navy planes flying close to the sting of Alaska’s restricted airspace. These safety considerations “drove our give attention to the Arctic and the discharge of a method.”

Wargames organized by the U.S. navy and allies usually have centered on “countering nice powers particularly in Europe and within the Asia Pacific,” Hinote mentioned. “And one of many issues that we felt like we didn’t perceive as effectively was how that competitors would spill over into the Arctic.”

Dwell navy workout routines like NATO’s Chilly Response, NORAD’s Operation Noble Defender, and Northern Command’s Arctic Edge are serving to the U.S. and allies “perceive the character of the competitors,” he mentioned. The submarine-focused Ice Train (ICEX) has been held for the reason that Sixties, making it the longest-running Arctic train.

To bolster the U.S. posture within the Arctic, the Air Power is stationing 54 F-35 superior fighter plane at Eielson Air Power Base, Alaska.

“Alaska is an extremely well-positioned base of operations for defending the northern approaches to the USA, and this is the reason so lots of the intercepts that occur when an adversary’s plane is coming from the north are accomplished with property which might be stationed in Alaska,” Hinote mentioned.

The Division of the Air Power’s Arctic technique additionally recommends higher use of area property to assist navy and homeland protection efforts.

“House capabilities are tailored to assist a area the place there’s sparse floor infrastructure,” Lt. Gen. William Liquori, deputy chief of area operations for technique, plans and applications for the U.S. House Power, mentioned on the Wilson Middle panel.

“The satellite tv for pc command-and-control capabilities that we’ve got at Thule, these are there as a result of navy operations are going to occur within the Arctic,” mentioned Liquori. “And which means we’re going to wish to have satellite tv for pc protection within the Arctic.”

To fill gaps in satellite tv for pc communications protection over the Arctic, the Air Power labored out a cope with the Norwegian House Company subsidiary House Norway to launch two U.S. navy communications payloads on Norwegian satellites. The payloads, developed by Northrop Grumman, might be built-in into the Arctic Satellite tv for pc Broadband Mission satellites, projected to launch on a SpaceX rocket in 2023.

Any Arctic technique has to think about the significance of the area area, mentioned Mir Sadat, a nonresident fellow on the Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Middle for Technique and Safety.

The US is just not doing sufficient to “put together for the brand new frontier.” In distinction, Russia and China, by growing their actions within the area, are positioning to sooner or later benefit from shorter sea lanes, Sadat mentioned. A key objective for China and Russia is to “attain international markets or navy targets sooner and rather more cheaply,” he mentioned.

Satellites to observe what Russia and others are doing on the bottom is one other vital functionality that the USA may must broaden, mentioned Scott Herman, CEO of Cognitive House.

The corporate participated within the current Arctic Edge 2022 train as a navy contractor, orchestrating assortment alternatives throughout industrial satellite tv for pc operators.

In the present day, many industrial remote-sensing constellations can’t assist Arctic actions as a result of they will’t attain these excessive latitudes, mentioned Herman. But when the Arctic turns into a geopolitical flashpoint, “you may even see some changes to a few of the satellite tv for pc constellation plans to ensure they’ve obtained enough northern publicity.”

In its technique, the Division of the Air Power mentioned there’s a want for “area consciousness by new applied sciences starting from over the horizon radar to area property.”


Michael Sfraga, chair and distinguished fellow of the Wilson Middle’s Polar Institute, mentioned an imminent conflict within the Arctic is unlikely.

“I feel that’s a low likelihood,” mentioned Sfraga, who relies in Alaska. However he believes the danger will improve as nations step up actions.

“The upper likelihood, sadly, is a miscommunication: An train gone incorrect, a missile fired by mistake, Russian bombers are escorted out of our airspace and there’s a miscommunication between pilots,” he mentioned.

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine now casts issues in a unique gentle, he added. “Nobody thought one thing like Ukraine would truly occur. If anyone would have advised you 20 years in the past that China would have constructed islands within the South China Sea and claimed that territory, I’d have mentioned that appears fairly far-fetched.” The lesson for the USA is to stay “vigilant and diligent.”

It’s well-known that Russia derives a good portion of its GDP from pure useful resource improvement within the Arctic, Sfraga mentioned. It’s additionally persevering with to broaden its navy presence and capabilities within the area. “China, which generally forgets that it’s not truly an Arctic state, is doing the whole lot it will probably to ascertain its personal affect in Arctic governance and financial improvement.”

“Whereas there’s no imminent menace of battle within the Arctic, the growing exercise and proximity of those aggressive powers requires the U.S. to take care of situational consciousness and operational capability,” he mentioned.

The US must be higher ready to function within the Arctic, Sfraga mentioned, and famous that satellite-based companies are sorely wanted within the space.

“Satellite tv for pc communications, imagery, all of these issues are crucial to our nationwide and civil safety, search and rescue,” he mentioned. “There’s simply restricted capability.”

“Presence equals affect,” he mentioned. “Exhibiting potential adversaries which you can truly conduct operations and defend your personal pursuits in a panorama just like the Arctic serves as a deterrent and is extremely necessary.”

This text initially appeared within the Could 2022 situation of table4 journal.

Recommended For You

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.